By Benjamin Braun, Editor-in-Chief
Some of our readers might be interested to know that the February 2017 Notices of the American Mathematical Society contains an article on active learning that is based on the six-part series on active learning published on this blog in Fall 2015. See the Notices article here:
“What Does Active Learning Mean for Mathematicians?” Benjamin Braun, Priscilla Bremser, Art M. Duval, Elise Lockwood, Diana White. Notices of the American Mathematical Society, Vol 64, Number 2, February 2017.
We read and very much appreciated the confirming piece, “What Does
Active Learning Mean for Mathematicians?” in the current issue of the
Notices of the AMS. Congratulations on a work well done.
While much of what the authors bring forward is “not new news,” the forum in
which you offered it truly is NEW, namely the Notices of the AMS. The
organization and presentation were very engaging, with rich
illustrations to which readers could relate. As a former Editor (I
founded the journal PRIMUS years ago) I appreciated the elegance in
your writing and your narrative approach.
As a long standing member of AMS – over 50 years and as well with MAA –
I am so pleased to see the Society turning more and more of its
publication pages to teaching (while still maintaining its strong and
supportive efforts on research) the very mathematics which is the core
of the research effort in mathematics. Indeed, a few weeks ago at the
Joint Mathematics Meeting in Atlanta we offered an AMS Special Session
on The Modeling First Approach to Teaching Differential Equations.
This was one of the first such sessions the AMS offered which was
solely devoted to teaching. We suffered the lack of attendance due to
the weather “panic” that caused folks to leave Atlanta early, but we had
reasonable attendance and some remarkable talks.
I particularly appreciated the article’s words, “. . . lecturing in order to
cover more material is not always effective for students. By exclusively
considering course content coverage and responding to content coverage
with telling, we risk forgetting the many other elements of student
learning that active learning addresses, such as the cognitive goals for
students outlined in the 2015 MAA CUPM Curriculum Guide.” The fear (in
some case excuse) that faculty have for not using active learning that
coverage will be lost is simply not supported.
I have been in the active learning camp for years, indeed, once engaged
in active learning there is a sort of guilt feeling that happens if one
has to “drop back and punt” by going to lecture. Nevertheless, there are
times when we need to just tell them so min-lectures are not plain bad.
Years ago Kurt Bryan, a colleague at Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology
in Terre Haute IN co-taught a differential equations course and we
taught in very active mode, with in class modeling projects. On course
end evaluations the students said essentially, “We really liked when you
were ‘on’ and produced quality activities for us, but we did not like
when you were not ‘on’ and lectured.” They can tell the difference and
they know when they are engaging and learning. Hopefully, colleagues who
read your piece and who try to engage in more active learning get good
student feedback. However, Karl Smith of Purdue University’s Engineering
Education program, told me years ago that it can take as much as 5 years
to be proficient in active learning techniques, but he also said once
there you will not go back to lecturing. So true!
Now while I have your attention I want to share something we are working
on now which is an ultimate active learning effort, namely, teaching
differential equations using a modeling-first approach. We call it
SIMIODE – Systemic Initiative for Modeling Investigations and
Opportunities with Differential Equations. SIMIODE is about teaching
differential equations using modeling and technology upfront and
throughout the learning process. You can learn more at our dynamic
website, www.simiode.org, where we offer a community in which colleagues
can communicate, collaborate, publish, teach, explore, contribute, etc.
Check us out.
Finally and again, we should all thank and applaud the AUTHORS and THE Editors of the Notices of the AMS for this terrific piece.
PS I was particularly impressed with the Middlebury images as my wife is
a Midd grad!!!